A very interesting article was published in the Boston Globe today. Apparently, there is a growing movement to provide nature with legal rights. A town in Maine made it possible for residents to file lawsuits on behalf of "natural assets." This was brought about as a proactive action against the Nestle Company in case they attempted to tap the local aquifer for it's bottled water products.
On one level, this seems to be an absurd over reaction and perhaps even a prime example of the hyper-litigious culture that exists today. On the other hand, two of the ways society can assign value are to place a monetary value upon it and to give it legal rights. The article points out [o]ther nonhuman entities have long enjoyed certain rights under our legal system: ships and corporations are two examples of entities entitled to “personhood,” meaning they can bring lawsuits to court. The notion that corporations are essentially people in the current legal structure has bothered me deeply, both as an expression of structural evil, and as an example of how the idea of inalienable rights has been divorced from the idea of inalienable responsibilites, ie. the social contract theory. But, I digress.
Upon reflection, I think that I'm also intrigued by the theological implications that this debate might open up. The idea of "personhood" in a legal sense leaning closer towards the idea of pantheism or panentheism; endowing nature with divine presence, as well as revisiting the Biblical story of Genesis, where humanity was installed as either caretakers or dominators of nature, depending on how Genesis is read. It also reminds me of the Talmudic debates about the nature of the golem, a humanoid creation of clay, whether it counted as a person for the minyan, the Jewish prayer circle, or the destruction of a golem would be considered murder or destruction of property.
Of course, another argument can be made that we are projecting human values and concerns onto nature by entering lawsuits on their behalf. The article also speaks to this position, and highlights it better than I think I could. A counter to this concern is that a similar issue could be found with ships and people as non-human "persons," as it isn't the bodies themselves, but rather humans speaking on their behalves that actually has the legal standing.
In short, re-visiting how society views nature is a very serious matter, with significant economic, religious, and political repercussions. In so far as it is an extra layer of protection for the environment, I support the effort, though I need to learn more before I'm fully convinced. It does seem like a neat solution to the issue with corporations being legal entities, though. In closing, the article points out another interesting fact, "What’s more, proponents say, the extension of rights invariably seems absurd before it happens. When the economy depended on slave labor, emancipation was unfathomable even to many who abhorred slavery. In retrospect, though, it seems morally imperative and historically inevitable."
This entry was posted
on Monday, July 20, 2009
at Monday, July 20, 2009
and is filed under
Bible,
economics,
environment,
legal,
politics,
society,
sustainability
. You can follow any responses to this entry through the
comments feed
.
About Me
- Bushel Basket
- Chicago, Il, United States
- A non-traditional seminary graduate. Interested in sustainability, embodying spirituality and faith, interfaith practices, and using humor as a method of truth telling.
Categories
Blog Archive
- October 2011 (1)
- August 2011 (1)
- June 2011 (1)
- April 2011 (2)
- February 2011 (1)
- November 2010 (2)
- October 2010 (2)
- May 2010 (1)
- March 2010 (2)
- December 2009 (2)
- November 2009 (2)
- August 2009 (4)
- July 2009 (1)
- June 2009 (3)
- May 2009 (3)
- March 2009 (1)
- February 2009 (3)
- January 2009 (7)
- December 2008 (8)
- November 2008 (5)
- October 2008 (3)
- September 2008 (8)
- August 2008 (1)
- July 2008 (5)
- June 2008 (6)
- May 2008 (5)
- April 2008 (5)
- March 2008 (12)
- February 2008 (1)
Other Websites Worth Visiting
- Anti-Advertising Agency
- EcoGeek: Technology for the Environment
- illdoctrine.com
- Life Hackery: Useful, Unusual, and (sometimes) Ironic Tips and Tricks to Hack Your Life into Shape
- Ship of Fools: The Magazine of Christian Unrest
- Skeptic's Annotated Bible
- Superuse.org: Where Recycling Meets Design
- The Brick Testament: The World's Largest, Most Comprehensive Illustrated Bible
- WikiHow: The How-to Manual That You Can Edit
Subscribe
Subscribe to Email Subscription
My Blog List
-
-
Bestway Frame Pool 412X201X1222 years ago
-
kiddos and call5 years ago
-
Hello world!6 years ago
-
2015 Fic Year in Review8 years ago
-
What To Fear8 years ago
-
-
-
Fishing on Morrison Lake13 years ago
-